超越儿童生存:儿童期起病复杂慢性病对成人医院系统的不成比例影响

超越儿童生存:儿童期起病复杂慢性病对成人医院系统的不成比例影响

研究亮点

最近发表在《JAMA Network Open》的一项大规模队列研究对儿童期起病复杂慢性病(4Cs)如何影响成人医疗保健基础设施进行了关键评估。主要发现包括:

1. 资源使用不成比例:4Cs患者仅占住院年轻人的5.4%,但消耗了所有年轻人住院天数的10.7%。

2. 住院时间延长和成本增加:该组的住院时间比无这些疾病的同龄人长62%,费用高65%。

3. 再入院风险高:4Cs年轻人的30天再入院风险高59%,表明出院后稳定性和门诊支持存在挑战。

4. 工具不足:Charlson共病指数(CCI),一种用于预测死亡率和资源使用的标准工具,未能准确捕捉4C人群的临床复杂性。

引言:儿科成功的悖论

几十年来,儿科医学的主要目标是生存。新生儿重症监护、囊性纤维化管理、先天性心脏病手术和遗传性贫血治疗的进步已将曾经致命的儿童诊断转变为可管理的慢性病。如今,大多数患有复杂慢性病的儿童能够存活到成年。然而,这一成功带来了次级挑战:一个不断增长的年轻人群体,其医疗需求不符合传统的成人医疗模式。

成人导向的医院系统主要是为了管理急性疾病或与老龄化相关的慢性病,如2型糖尿病、冠状动脉疾病和慢性阻塞性肺病。25岁患有脑瘫或30岁因先天性心脏病接受Fontan循环的年轻成年人的医疗复杂性呈现独特的生理和心理社会挑战。直到现在,这些患者对成人急性护理系统的影响尚未得到充分量化。Malecki等人的研究(2026)试图通过分析加拿大医疗保健背景下这一人群的特征和结果来填补这一知识空白。

研究方法:评估安大略省的经验

这项回顾性队列研究利用了加拿大安大略省29家医院的数据,涵盖了从社区医院到四级学术中心的各种临床环境。研究对象包括2018年1月至12月期间出院的15,072名18至39岁的患者。主要暴露因素是存在一种或多种儿童期起病复杂慢性病(4Cs),使用改进的儿科算法进行识别。

研究人员采用倾向评分重叠权重法平衡4C和非4C队列在年龄、性别和社会经济地位等各种基线特征上的差异。这种方法学严谨性使得能够更准确地评估4Cs与医院结果之间的独立关联。主要结果集中在住院时间(LOS)、院内死亡率和重症监护室(ICU)入住率。次要结果包括总医疗费用、药物负担、高级影像学检查(CT/MRI)的使用和30天再入院率。

详细结果:量化住院负担

在分析的近20,000例住院病例中,6.7%与患有儿童期起病复杂慢性病的患者相关。虽然这一百分比看似较低,但对医院容量的影响却相当显著。这些患者占据了13,606个床位日,占整个18-39岁年龄段总床位日的10.7%。

常见疾病和患者概况

在4C队列中,最常见的疾病是遗传性贫血(26.0%)、囊性纤维化(17.0%)和脑瘫(11.8%)。有趣的是,4C患者的Charlson共病指数(CCI)得分低于非4C组。4C组中只有0.9%的患者CCI得分为3或更高,而对照组为2.8%。这一差异凸显了使用标准成人风险分层工具评估这一人群的根本缺陷;CCI关注的是心肌梗死和恶性肿瘤等在4Cs年轻人中罕见的疾病,而忽略了先天性和儿童期起病疾病的多系统需求。

临床和经济结果

统计分析显示结果差异显著。即使在调整了潜在混杂因素后,4Cs患者的住院时间也显著延长(相对比[RR],1.62;95%置信区间[CI],1.48-1.77)。这直接导致总费用增加(RR,1.65;95% CI,1.05-2.59)。药物负担也较高,这些患者在住院期间接受的处方药物增加了26%。

更令人担忧的是30天再入院率。4Cs患者在出院后一个月内的再入院风险高59%。这表明这一群体从急性护理返回社区的过渡特别脆弱。有趣的是,ICU入住率和院内死亡率没有显著差异。这表明,虽然这些患者需要更多的时间和资源来稳定病情,但他们并不一定在标准住院期间比其他有急性医疗需求的年轻人面临更高的急性死亡风险。

高级影像学趋势

一个值得注意的次要发现是,4Cs患者接受的高级影像学检查较少(RR,0.85)。这可能反映了这些患者中许多人的诊断已经确立,基础解剖结构或病理已经记录在案,减少了在急性发作期间重复诊断成像的需要。

诊断差距:为什么标准共病指数失效

对卫生系统管理者和临床医生的一个重要启示是,Charlson共病指数对这一人群的不适用性。由于CCI是在老年人群中验证以预测死亡率的,因此无法捕捉到4Cs年轻人所需的“护理强度”。一名囊性纤维化患者的CCI可能为0,但需要复杂的呼吸治疗、多学科营养支持和特定抗生素剂量——这些因素驱动了住院时间和成本。依赖传统指数进行医院资源规划或报销模型可能导致对这些复杂年轻人护理单元的严重资金不足和人员不足。

专家评论和临床解读

这项研究的结果强调了“医疗悬崖”的现实——即儿科患者向成人护理过渡的时期。在儿科世界中,护理通常是集中化的、多学科的和以家庭为中心的。当这些患者进入成人系统时,护理变得分散。成人内科医生可能对管理70岁的心力衰竭患者感到舒适,但可能不具备管理22岁患有复杂代谢障碍或神经发育障碍患者的细微差别的能力。

解决过渡差距

临床专家建议,研究中观察到的高再入院率是这种分散的直接结果。为了改善结果,医院应考虑实施“过渡医学”团队。这些团队通常由经过内外科培训的医生领导,充当桥梁,确保儿科环境中获得的专门知识被整合到成人住院管理计划中。

优化住院管理

鉴于住院时间延长1.62倍,医院应逐步淘汰“一刀切”的出院协议。对于4C患者,“成功”出院不仅需要临床稳定性,还需要家庭护理、专科门诊随访以及通常与社会服务的协调。研究建议优先考虑这一人群的强化出院计划,可以显著减少目前系统中的10.7%床位日负担。

结论:呼吁制定有针对性的住院策略

Malecki等人的研究表明,患有儿童期起病复杂慢性病的年轻人是成人医院系统中的高利用率、高风险群体。随着医疗技术的不断进步,儿科生存率提高,这些患者在成人病房的患病率只会增加。

研究结果倡导范式转变:我们必须停止将这些患者视为成人医院中的“儿科异常”,而是将其视为一个独特、可预测且重要的患者群体。通过开发专门的临床路径、完善风险调整工具以纳入4C特定标志物,并投资于强大的过渡计划,医疗系统可以提高这些年轻人的护理质量,同时优化医院资源利用。

参考文献

1. Malecki SL, Shen T, Loffler A, 等. 成人住院儿童期起病复杂慢性病的特征和结果. JAMA Netw Open. 2026;9(1):e2553610. doi:10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2025.53610

2. Cohen E, Berry JG, Camacho X, Anderson G, Wodchis W, Guttmann A. 复杂慢性病儿童的医疗保健使用. Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 2011;165(11):1020-1026.

3. Feudtner C, Feinstein JA, Zhong W, Hall M, Dai D. 儿童复杂慢性病分类系统版本2:更新适用于ICD-10和生存代码. BMC Pediatr. 2014;14:199.

Beyond Child Survival: The Evolving Global Burden of Lower Respiratory Infections and Emerging Pathogens (1990-2023)

Beyond Child Survival: The Evolving Global Burden of Lower Respiratory Infections and Emerging Pathogens (1990-2023)

Highlights

  • Lower respiratory infections (LRIs) resulted in 2.50 million deaths and 98.7 million DALYs globally in 2023, remaining the leading infectious cause of mortality.
  • Mortality among children younger than 5 years decreased by 33.4% since 2010, yet 129 of 204 countries have met the GAPPD target of fewer than 60 deaths per 100,000.
  • Streptococcus pneumoniae remains the leading LRI pathogen, responsible for 25.3% of all LRI deaths.
  • The inclusion of 11 newly modelled pathogens, including non-tuberculous mycobacteria and Aspergillus spp, accounts for approximately 22% of the global LRI death toll.

The Enduring Challenge of Lower Respiratory Infections

Lower respiratory infections (LRIs), primarily manifesting as pneumonia and bronchiolitis, continue to represent a formidable challenge to global health security. Despite decades of intervention through expanded vaccination programs and improved access to antibiotics, LRIs remain the world’s leading infectious cause of death. The Global Burden of Diseases, Injuries, and Risk Factors Study (GBD) 2023 provides a critical update on the landscape of LRI mortality and morbidity, offering a granular view of 26 pathogens across 204 countries and territories from 1990 to 2023.

This latest analysis is particularly significant as it introduces 11 newly modelled pathogens and assesses global progress toward the 2025 Global Action Plan for the Prevention and Control of Pneumonia and Diarrhoea (GAPPD) targets. As the world transitions out of the acute phase of the COVID-19 pandemic, understanding the baseline burden of endemic respiratory pathogens is essential for prioritizing public health resources and clinical research.

Study Design and Methodological Advancements

The GBD 2023 study utilized the Cause of Death Ensemble model (CODEm), integrating data from vital registration systems, verbal autopsies, surveillance programs, and minimally invasive tissue sampling. To estimate morbidity, the researchers employed DisMod-MR 2.1, a Bayesian meta-regression tool, to ensure consistency across incidence and prevalence data. A significant methodological leap in this iteration was the use of splined binomial regression to model pathogen-specific case-fatality ratios (CFRs), providing internally consistent estimates of mortality proportions attributable to viral, bacterial, fungal, and parasitic agents.

The study specifically focused on Disability-Adjusted Life-Years (DALYs), calculated as the sum of Years of Life Lost (YLLs) and Years Lived with Disability (YLDs). Progress was measured against the GAPPD target: a mortality rate of less than 3 deaths per 1,000 livebirths for children under five, which translates to roughly 60 deaths per 100,000 children.

Global Burden and Demographic Disparities

In 2023, LRIs were responsible for 2.50 million deaths (95% UI 2.24–2.81) and 98.7 million DALYs. The burden follows a distinct U-shaped distribution across the lifespan, with the highest impact observed in children younger than 5 years and adults aged 70 years and older. While the total number of deaths remains staggering, the data reveal a positive trend in pediatric survival. Since 2010, LRI mortality in children under five has fallen by 33.4%.

However, this progress is not uniform. Sub-Saharan Africa continues to bear a disproportionate share of the burden, with mortality rates in children under five remaining the furthest from the GAPPD targets. In contrast, the burden among the elderly (70+ years) has seen only marginal declines. As the global population ages, the relative contribution of older adults to the total LRI burden is expected to increase, presenting a dual challenge for health systems that must sustain pediatric gains while addressing the rising vulnerability of the geriatric population.

The Pathogen Landscape: Old Rivals and New Threats

The GBD 2023 analysis offers a comprehensive breakdown of the aetiologies driving LRI mortality.

Streptococcus pneumoniae

remains the most lethal pathogen, accounting for 634,000 deaths (25.3% of all LRI deaths). This underscores the continued need for high coverage of pneumococcal conjugate vaccines (PCV), particularly in low-income settings where access remains suboptimal.

Other major bacterial contributors include

Staphylococcus aureus

(271,000 deaths) and

Klebsiella pneumoniae

(228,000 deaths). These pathogens are of particular concern due to their association with antimicrobial resistance (AMR), which complicates treatment and increases the risk of mortality in hospital settings.

A landmark feature of the 2023 study is the inclusion of 11 newly modelled pathogens. These emerging or previously under-recognized aetiologies, including non-tuberculous mycobacteria (NTM) and Aspergillus spp, accounted for 22% of LRI deaths. NTM alone was responsible for 177,000 deaths, while Aspergillus spp contributed to 67,800 deaths. The identification of these pathogens as significant contributors to LRI mortality suggests a need for expanded diagnostic capabilities and targeted therapeutic strategies beyond traditional pneumonia protocols.

Expert Commentary: Bridging the Gap in Care

The findings of the GBD 2023 study highlight a critical intersection between epidemiology and health policy. Clinical experts note that while the reduction in pediatric mortality is a triumph of vaccination and nutritional interventions, the stagnation in older adult mortality and the persistent gap in sub-Saharan Africa indicate systemic failures in healthcare equity.

The emergence of NTM and fungal pathogens like Aspergillus as major killers suggests that our current clinical focus may be too narrow. In many high-burden regions, diagnostic tools are limited to sputum microscopy or basic radiology, which are insufficient for identifying these complex aetiologies. Furthermore, the rise of respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) as a major driver of pediatric hospitalizations calls for the rapid deployment of newer interventions, such as long-acting monoclonal antibodies (e.g., nirsevimab) and maternal immunization.

From a policy perspective, the fact that only 129 of 204 countries have met the GAPPD target indicates that the ‘last mile’ of pneumonia control will be the hardest. It requires not just vaccines, but also the strengthening of primary healthcare systems to ensure early diagnosis and the availability of therapeutic oxygen and appropriate antibiotics.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The GBD 2023 analysis serves as both a scorecard for past efforts and a roadmap for future interventions. The significant decline in child mortality proves that targeted public health strategies work. However, the high burden of LRIs in sub-Saharan Africa and the increasing vulnerability of the elderly population demand a recalibration of global health priorities. To achieve the GAPPD targets and reduce the global toll of LRIs, the international community must focus on equitable vaccine distribution, the development of diagnostics for emerging pathogens, and the integration of adult immunization programs into routine care.

Funding

This study was funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

References

  1. GBD 2023 Lower Respiratory Infections and Antimicrobial Resistance Collaborators. Global burden of lower respiratory infections and aetiologies, 1990-2023: a systematic analysis for the Global Burden of Disease Study 2023. Lancet Infect Dis. 2025 Dec 15. doi: 10.1016/S1473-3099(25)00689-9.
  2. UNICEF/WHO. Global Action Plan for the Prevention and Control of Pneumonia and Diarrhoea (GAPPD). 2013.
  3. Kyu HH, et al. Causes of death among children under 5 years in the GBD 2021 study. Lancet. 2024.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

发表回复